
Debra St.Lawrence Sussman |
|
The debate dominating the discussion around complementary care and fertility treatment centers on efficacy. Does it or doesn’t it work to improve outcome?
In a word, yes.
Clinical research has clearly established that when individuals and couples avail themselves of the comprehensive emotional and physical support embodied in complementary care, the chances of conception markedly improve. This information—and acting on it—is critical to the doctor/patient relationship, patient retention, and preserving women’s fertility.
Studies have found that women with acute and chronic stress from fertility treatment and medical procedures had 20% fewer eggs retrieved and 19% fewer eggs fertilized. Pregnancy rates, live birth rates and birth weight were adversely affected.
The culprits, the stress hormones cortisol and catacholomines, release from the brain through the nervous system. They attach to muscular receptors on cells throughout the body. They target organs, exhausting the adrenal glands, causing suppression of the hypothalamus, instigate hormonal changes, hypertension and muscle tension. Significantly, they suppress immunity and reproduction (Fricchioni, 2004).
Armed with findings such as these, programs like the Mind Body Institute, in growing partnership with fertility care providers, have been working to establish a medical model for Ob-Gyns and Reproductive Endocrinologists that integrates stress physiology and complementary care in treatment protocols.
A 2004 study indicates 40% of couples going through infertility treatment qualify for a psychiatric disorder. They range from generalized anxiety due to a medical condition to major depression. Researchers found those psychological states compromise decision making, ignite relationship conflicts, provoke insomnia and apathy. Anxiety and depression decrease executive functioning and nutrition, and spark a host of physical symptoms.
Research indicates fertility patients experience levels of depression and anxiety equal to cancer, HIV and heart disease (Domar, 1993). While medical practices routinely and actively incorporate emotional support and complementary care into treatment for those diseases, fertility healthcare providers find this support to be out of their scope of practice and need to refer their patients to allied professionals.
Legitimizing the compromised fertility experience as a health crisis is key to optimizing the outlook of any given couple. With each cycle they undergo, they are primed to gain knowledge about their bodies and their responses to stress and the protocols.
Patients report when doctors refer to or incorporate complementary health into their practice they are better equipped to deal with the unpredictability and failure of medicine to deliver a child. They report they feel their doctor has their best interest in mind.
A relatively constant stream of media reports on the personal experiences of women of all ages who benefit from complementary care reinforce the growing acceptance of these techniques. High-profile personalities such as Brenda Strong, Brooke Shields, Courtney Cox and Christie Brinkley use their celebrity platform to educate others about mind-body precisely because it worked for them in their reproductive difficulties.
With demand for complementary services soaring, the key is to establish a coherent model of patient and provider education and programming to seamlessly integrate such care into conventional medical fertility protocols. The goal is to maximize the positive patient outcomes—even if the desired goal of a take-home baby isn’t achieved.
Incorporating a comprehensive program with referrals to experts is responsible patient care. Why is this not common practice?
As one doctor at a prominent University clinic put it: “Stress reduction alone cannot treat the patient. Medical intervention is widely and judiciously used. Complementary care is in its infancy in terms of empirical evidence to stand on its own. Most doctors don’t understand the collaboration in healthcare and therefore discount the importance of mind-body.”
Through The Patient
People in treatment, however, feel differently. Kathy Younger reports that she, like many others, “doctor shop” to seek an OB-GYN and Reproductive Endocrinologist who normalizes her stress and has her overall health in mind. “Doctors realize their patients seek answers and due to consumer demand, are starting to incorporate and refer to complementary health as a marketing opportunity within their practice.”
“That the RE practice helps me normalize stress, I perceive that my doctor has my best interests at heart and hasn’t missed a thing,” Younger says.
|
When a couple enters an RE’s office after one year of unsuccessful attempts, they are panicked. They focus on the problem and not the solution they are there to seek.
In three different studies where cost was not a factor, over 64% of couples dropped out of treatment due to emotional distress (Olivius, et 2004). Dr. David Meldrum at Reproductive Partners and professionals at many other clinics recommend patients attend a stress reduction program simultaneously or prior to starting treatment. The more anxious and depressed a woman is before treatment, the more likely she is to terminate after one cycle (Domar, 2004).
Patients will go to extraordinary lengths on this journey to parenthood. But doctors must be cognizant that the unforeseen turns the path often takes can make the pressure feel unendurable. Maybe conception takes longer to achieve, or treatment is more costly than planned, or it’s the progression to increasingly high-tech interventions that ratchet up the tension.
The mind-body goal is to provide patients with techniques to keep in check the understandable angst that can compromise treatment.
Julie Nitodian, a “graduate” of the Mind Body Institute’s Fertility Wellness program, said the approach and techniques “…helped me navigate through the difficult decisions and the failures I had along the way and gave me hope as I visualized my success for a baby.” Julie still uses the tools learned as she parents her 5-year old daughter.
Some doctors are incorporating complementary medicine precisely because it is compatible with and augments existing fertility treatments.
If the RE is like the pilot of the plane, stress educators are the stewards making the process a more manageable and positive experience. As a team, they often reach the destination with little to no turbulence.
Providing a comprehensive list of the full panel of tests, both general and advanced, surgeries, and possible drug protocols, educates the patient on the process even if they may or may not ever use most of the tests. Without it no wonder women seek information and answers on the internet, chat rooms, and peer groups only to bring about inaccurate misinformation to dispel.
It can be overwhelming to a patient at first but assuming they have the ability to be educated, it is easier to manage the list of protocols upfront than to manage a stressed out patient after a failed cycle. Perhaps even leaving the patient open to seek another opinion and question the doctor’s credibility no matter how reputable.
Having tools to help minimize the difficulty, positive affirmations, mindfulness in everyday living, good nutrition and looking for the good in their day can
strengthen their reserve. Many times this is the key to success as research indicates a 55% increase in conception rates after using a medical model with mind body medicine.
Women often find themselves abducted into an unknown world, waiting for that magic bullet and cure. Waiting for that perfect strategy, they lose themselves in the process. Many vacations are put on hold due to monitored appointments, and their family and friends proceed into parenthood leaving them behind.
There is hope in helping reduce the unpredictability in treatment through “Fertility Wellness Education”. Conception is one piece of a women’s potential, the other is overall good health, lifestyle, hormones, metabolism/nutrition and stress management. Regardless if a patient is with an OB/GYN or Advanced Reproductive Endocrinologist, knowing the steps and what to expect during treatment and conception gives them the big picture. They can put themselves in the diagram and make accurate appraisals and decisions along the way
Complementary medicine is consumer driven where couples want the best outcome for their investment and optimize their chances.
Medical interventions are highly effective when using complementary medicine. It increases not only the chances of conception, it increases the ability to respond positively to the fertility experience along the way. For example, if a cycle did not end in a pregnancy, is not necessarily a failed cycled as a wealth of information was gained about how their bodies respond.
OB/GYN’s and Reproductive Endocrinologists have the responsibility and opportunity to partner with and refer to support the compromised fertile couple. Early education about complementary medicine and its impact on health can prepare patients to effectively deal with the stressors of treatment resulting in a more satisfied patient and increased patient retention. It fosters a positive doctor-patient relationship and, in the end, increases chance of conception.
By: Debra St.Lawrence Sussman, MA
Executive Director
The Mind Body Institute – A Fertility Wellness Program
(www.mindbodyinfertility.com).
UCLA – 213-688-6119
Newport Beach, CA – 949-412-2466
:: return to top of page :: |